O Livro de Eli

Não há ação suficiente para um filme de ação (há duas lutas de facas, duram apenas um minuto e não são físicas, mas apenas icónicas; + um tiroteio estático). Para um drama com uma mensagem, infantilmente vulgar, com alguns momentos WTF (a prova de bala de Washington, ligações estranhas do enredo, o incómodo e principalmente desnecessário ponto de partida no final). A atmosfera pós-apocalíptica depende fortemente do orçamento do filme, o talento dos realizadores não é suficiente para ela (Exterminador Implacável - A Salvação significativamente mais caro, com toda a sua estupidez, era muito mais sexy). Os atores não têm nada para representar, o espetador não tem nada para ser devidamente entretido. Se eu dei as três estrelas Eu Sou a Lenda mais interessante visualmente e de conteúdo, tenho de ficar com duas aqui. (11/01/2010)

While having faith play the main role doesn’t bother me, I would have imagined it a little differently. I'm glad it wasn't just a simple-minded shooter, though. On the other hand, D. Washington was loaded with too much goodness. Not enough badass lines, cleverness, and conviction. But I still find it touching that he memorized the entire Bible. (20/04/2011)

A few knife fights and one bigger shootout do not make an action epic. And what's worse, one suspicious punchline and a few attempts at existential dialogues do not create a drama at all. The survival book stumbles from nowhere to nowhere, the actors meander precisely into their predictable boxes, and everything ends with one big question mark as to whether this is meant seriously. With a reasonable distance, it is still a weaker, disjointed nothingness that holds a few glimpses of post-apocalyptic atmosphere beyond the one-star threshold. (11/12/2010)

One of the most ridiculously WTF stupid things I’ve seen this year. The atmosphere is alright, and so are the performances, the problem is that I am not able to get over the twist, which is utterly pointless and pulled out of a (religious) ass, notwithstanding its outcome, which is just idiotic. The dialogues are toe curling (the Bible), Denzel fights better than Chuck Norris and The Book of Eli was an annoying film experiences. 30 % (31/05/2010)

I can see why Joel Silver tried to sell this film as a spectacular post-apocalyptic action flick. When the Hughes brothers presented him with the final cut, it must have been clear that he had poured eighty million into something that would never come back for the rest of his life. The Book of Eli is quite an unconventional road movie, which in its symbiotic audio/video position has an almost meditative effect. It's strange that even the few moments that get going (all of which were then furiously edited into the trailer) fit in and don't distract from it all. My only criticism is directed at the screenwriter, who sometimes lets the meaningfulness of the plot slip through his fingers. It's unfortunate that, according to the reviews, many were expecting another Terminator with the added bonus of a shocking point, which you can guess from the plot outline (and the poster), so there’s no point in ranting about it. (28/05/2010)