MrHlad

A very good children's film, which paradoxically will be enjoyed more by adults and older kids. It's a pity the middle part loses a bit of pace. And those kids can act surprisingly well!

The animated passages are great, the acting is terrible. If Luc Besson had taken more care and kept the pace and especially the atmosphere at the same level all the time, it could have been very good. As it is, it alternates boredom with enthusiasm.

Awesome. Amélie, but even more intense, fantastic and original. A romantic film for people who haven't lost their imagination.

Good actors, an interesting script (or idea) and hopelessly boring visuals. A solid thriller for a dull evening, but lacking enough to step out of Saw's shadow.

It's as if Clint Eastwood and Paul Haggis worked with an unfinished version of the script. Sometimes there's something missing, sometimes there's too much of something (god, the ending!!!) and mostly it's pretty boring. Fortunately, the landing and the ensuing battle almost match the opening of Saving Private Ryan, but it can't fix the overall impression. A mediocre film and a missed chance for more Oscars.

Emilio Estevez the director is quite good, but Emilio Estevez the screenwriter is lost. The film doesn't let you get beneath the surface and watching more than a dozen characters is basically quite boring. If Bobby had reduced the number of characters and given them more personality, it could have been much better.

A big surprise for me. I knew Will Smith could act well, but I didn’t expect that the ordinary story about a man trying to come back to normal life from rock bottom could be made in such an entertaining and fresh way. Although I approached the film with skepticism at the beginning, at the end I was left with nothing but satisfaction from a job well done without any major mistakes.

Not great. A story that's been told hundreds of times in an unremarkable setting. Ashton Kutcher is wooden, Kevin Costner somehow manages, and Andrew Davis is good, but there's simply nothing to surprise and the running time could have been shortened a bit.

The third one just recycles what we already saw in the previous one. It's good for one viewing, but otherwise it's just riding the wave of a popular property that doesn't bring anything new to the table. It's pretty boring.

Pretty cheesy, pretty long, and pretty superficial compared to the source material. Still, a pretty entertaining film.